It has been a long time since I last blogged. Since that time many new rules, guidance and opinions of the mortgage industry have changed. I will be posting more about the future of lending in subsequent blogs.
The Frank Dodd Bill has dramatically changed the landscape of the financial service industry. Like most government bills, the intent of bill was to protect consumers and the economy against the mistakes of the past. Unfortunately the unintended consequences have added to a moribund recovery, limited access to credit for millions of Americans and created more paperwork than you can imagine.
To appreciate how we got to this point, one must understand the history of the mortgage industry and how we arrived at this day. When I entered the industry in 1992 there were only a few classes of lenders:
- A-quality lenders that offered the best terms to full doc, very good credit clients.
- B&C-quality lenders that offered loans to borrowers at 2-6% higher than the rates that A-quality clients qualified for. B&C-quality clients had a various credit and qualifying issues. Some were slow payers, some had inconsistent income patterns and some had a major negative credit events like foreclosures or bankruptcies on their file.
- Hard Money lenders. These lenders made lending decisions based primarily on the equity of the property. Lending to people solely because their property had equity often resulted in forced sales and foreclosures because the lenders did not look at the entire picture.
Through the 1990’s and into the early 2000’s it was a fun time to be in the mortgage industry. When ACC was formed on May 13, 1999 it was formed with the mission statement that we could find the right loan for the borrower. Because we started out as a broker we had access to hundreds, if not thousands of different loan programs. I always prided myself on the statement “If we can’t find a loan for you, no one can!” Although it may sound arrogant, I was never proven wrong. Those where good times.
In my opinion, the beginning of the mortgage problems can be directly traced to the stated income loans. For a small segment of the population these loans work. Business owners with viable businesses and other sources of payment are good candidates for stated income loans. The early stated income programs typically requested proof of 5 years self employment, then it was 2 years, then a letter from an accountant and finally it was whatever your wrote on the 1003. NO-DOC loans were similar to stated income loans, but they required at least 25% equity of down payment. These clients had high credit scores and where typically business owners or people that had large amounts of money in the bank and where willing to risk a large amount of equity or down payment for a house. By the end days on the mortgage industry you had 100% stated income/No-Doc loans for marginal credit quality candidates with very limited credit history.
I do not need to retell the implosion of the mortgage industry but a good book to read is The Big Short if you want to learn more about what was happening behind the scenes and how a few people made a lot of money.
Now we’re looking to the future with new rules and a long term history of mortgage lending to understand where the opportunity lies and how to properly lend in this market. The answer is very simple: You must have loans at higher rates! “What?!”, you say. We need to lower rates, that’s what the newspapers and Bernake and cheaper rates are better than higher rates!!! The mortgage industry and Wall Street need to offer safe and affordable products. Affordable doesn’t mean the cheapest but it means appropriate for the borrower. It means commiserate with their situation based on credit, income, capital and character.
The response/joke I would always offer to friends and referrals when they asked me how much of a loan I could get them 10 years ago was “I’ll get you a $2MM loan, but after 3 months when you can’t pay anymore and you have used up your savings you will be out on the street!” The mistake banks/lenders/Wall Street made in the mortgage implosion was trying to take away the human element of underwriting a loan.
ACC mortgage is in the fortunate position to have funds to lend to people of all situations that are being overlooked by the banks and other mortgage companies. Our lending decisions are based on understanding what is safe for the borrower and safe for us the lender. No one wins if a loan doesn’t perform.
